The conviction of Russell Brand and the newly published allegations surrounding David Walliams have brought an uncomfortable question into focus – how much are we prepared to overlook when someone is exceptionally talented, charismatic or successful?
The two cases are legally very different. Russell Brand has been convicted of rape and sexual assault. David Walliams faces allegations of sexual misconduct, which he denies, but both have prompted wider questions about celebrity, power and the environments in which powerful personalities operate.
In my book “Holding the Frame” I wrote a piece called The Hidden Cost of Brilliance, reflecting on what decades of working with extraordinary talent in broadcasting, advertising and creative leadership had taught me – and the quiet role that makes it sustainable.
Many brilliant people are rewarded early for behaviours that may later cost them. They thrive in environments where confidence, charisma and even controversy are rewarded. These attributes can be mesmerising for insiders and observers alike. Public affirmation becomes oxygen. Ratings, applause, algorithms and even outrage form a feedback loop that can slowly replace internal reflection.
In high-performing environments, there are invariably people working quietly behind the scenes. Managers, producers, partners, advisers and colleagues who absorb volatility, anticipate fallout, smooth relationships and keep things functioning. I have described this as the containment role – the often invisible work of holding the frame around exceptional talent.
But what happens when the people and systems that make brilliance possible also protect it from accountability?
At its best, containment provides perspective, structure and boundaries. It allows talent to flourish without overwhelming everyone around it but… where does containment end and enabling begin?
It’s not always an obvious distinction. Loyalty can become protection. Understanding can become rationalisation. The desire to preserve a successful business, programme or relationship can gradually take precedence over confronting uncomfortable behaviour. And the more successful the individual, the greater the incentive to look the other way.
People surrounding powerful personalities respond to the needs and demands of the person at the centre. Those relationships, however, are rarely one-dimensional. Admiration, identification, loyalty and personal ambition can all influence what people are prepared to tolerate. Sometimes we’re also drawn to exceptional personalities because they represent qualities we admire, envy or wish we possessed ourselves.
This isn’t necessarily conscious. We – organisations and individuals – adapt to powerful personalities. What might initially be regarded as unacceptable becomes an eccentricity, then a characteristic, and eventually part of the culture. Those who challenge it risk being seen as difficult, disloyal or simply unable to appreciate genius. The very qualities that make someone commercially valuable can also make them almost impossible to challenge.
None of this suggests that exceptional talent inevitably produces destructive behaviour, or that everyone working around a powerful personality is complicit. But it does raise questions about responsibility, particularly when warning signs are repeatedly dismissed.
Then there is the question of transformation. We live in a culture fascinated by brilliance, captivated by controversy and increasingly invested in the spectacle of redemption.
Russell Brand’s religious conversion and personal reinvention have become part of the public debate surrounding his conviction. Some believe he has genuinely changed, while others are more sceptical. But whatever the sincerity of that transformation, does the passage of time remove accountability for past crimes? Can people truly change?
My early training as a psychiatric social worker taught me never to underestimate the human capacity for growth, insight and transformation. But change is not absolution. A person may embrace religion, become more reflective, develop different values or genuinely regret their past behaviour, but none of that removes responsibility for the harm caused along the way.
And how do we know when it’s genuine transformation or a new public performance, particularly when the person concerned has spent a lifetime commanding an audience?
Perhaps we can’t – at least not from the outside. Transformation is ultimately demonstrated through sustained behaviour, accountability and the willingness to face uncomfortable truths – not simply through a compelling new narrative.
There is another uncomfortable aspect to this debate. When attention shifts to whether a celebrated personality has changed, the people affected by their earlier behaviour can once again become peripheral to the story. The star remains centre stage. Even the fall from grace becomes another chapter in the celebrity narrative.
Which brings me back to Russell Brand and David Walliams. Their circumstances are different and the distinction between conviction and allegation is important. But both cases invite us to examine not only the individuals at the centre, but the people and systems around them. What was rewarded? What was tolerated? And who, if anyone, challenged the behaviour?
Looking back over my own career, I still believe exceptional talent needs people who can hold the frame. But holding the frame responsibly also means holding the boundaries. The real test of containment isn’t how much difficult behaviour we can absorb, but whether we can create the conditions in which brilliance and accountability can coexist.
Talent may explain why people overlook behaviour, but it should never justify what they overlook.
Rina Broomberg: Founder of Podcast Party and Author: Holding the Frame: Lessons from the Edge of Brilliance